Toni Braxton once said that “Singers are a dime a dozen and record companies have a dollar to spend” meaning that singers were a relatively cheap commodity. You could probably cast a net and be reasonably sure to catch quite a few choice ”fishes”. But then there is David Archuleta who is not your ordinary, garden variety singer. His is the kind of voice that comes along once in awhile which when embellished with a sensitive, soulful nature, results in a vocal virtuosity that shakes the senses. A voice that cuts through you with its intensity and emotional spear. This “impaling” is all the more cogent when David sings live. In the music industry studio manipulation and “engineering” can make even me sound like Placido Domingo [ Kylie
]. It is in a live setting that the true abilities of a singer comes forth and is laid open for all to savour or not. In this environment David is a master as all the subtle hues of his vocals are displayed in a wondrous spectrum. All the technical wizadry of his vocal training comes through so natural and unforced. I feel that his studio works seldom capture this palette and his debut album, on the whole, is no exception other than a few moments here and there. But this doesn’t mean I’m not in favour of the album rather I hope that future producers would take the time to work with David and try to encapsulate the honesty and sincerity that he brings to his live performance. As for the sessions, I have listened to it ( multiple times I must add
) and conclude that David is one of those individuals who sound just as good live if not better as he does on cd. This is no easy feat as many a “singer” have been found to be woefully inadequate when you thrust them onto the stage.
First off Crush is easily his best live performance of this song thus far. He is supremely comfortable and at ease with the song and this time his band has eased off on the robustness of their musical backing which allows David’s voice to be heard more clearly. He has improved by leaps and bounds with singing Crush live. ALTNOY has that pop-rock vibe here – in fact all of the songs ( other than You Can ) has such a feeling – which lends it a more potent sound. I especially like the guitar riffs in the background. Now surprisingly TMH is my favourite of the sessions although on the cd I feel its overprocessed. Again the pop-rock beat here is simply addictive and I find myself bopping my head to the beat which I don’t when listening to the song on the cd. There’s more “muscle” to the song and I really like the vocal harmonizing with his band. You can also see that his band members are really getting into the groove of the song which has turned out to be a really great number when performed live. My Hands is a really difficult song to sing live as the transition from verse to chorus is done in a heartbeat. There’s hardly time for David to pause and catch his breath! But he does it with aplomb and if ever he feels like adding twists to the song as he gets more comfortable with it, it’ll be a great crowd puller at a concert. But even at this juncture David’s vocals just sells the song with its sensual lower notes and the tense yearning of the higher reaches. Plus that smile at the end. I’m conflicted with You Can as I feel that David glossed over the treatment of this song as I didn’t feel much of the passion. It felt strangely flat and colourless to me and you’ll probably accuse me of being sacrilegious when I say this as most if not all of us feel that his particular forte is ballads. But try as I might – even after repeated hearings – I couldn’t feel the emotions as I usually do when he sings ballads. That’s why I’m a bit nonplussed here. What do you guys think?
But the sessions have only reinforced the fact that David is an extraordinarily gifted vocalist especially when he sings live. It is as if he blooms and blossoms in full on the stage. Like Randy says, he was born to do this and you can see it in his demeanour when he sings, clutching that mic stand while he throws his whole being into the songs fully enjoying the moment and in turn drawing us in. I can’t tear my eyes away, he’s incandescant and his vocal faculties acquire that extra edge and magnitude that is yet to be fully captured on cd. It’s so great to see him front and center in the videos and he has, in a short time, gelled very well with his band and they seem to have forged a cohesive unit. The songs sounds amazing in these sessions with David at vocals accompanied by a live band and together they imbue a maturity and integrity to the music which is not so obvious otherwise. The clear conclusion to draw here is that all David needs are just drums, guitars, keyboard and he’s good enough to go. There’s no need for gimmicky, superflous studio machinations to drown his musicality with vapid, saccharine sweetnesss – future producers take note.
I see the sparkle of a million flashlights, a wonderwall of stars but the one that’s shining out so bright is the one right where you, David Archuleta, are.
Now if only he’ll make his way over to our part of the world for a concert.
- John

John, you did it again. I like to comment more but I have to run. I heard from those who attended his live performances, he sounds Better in live.
Hope to catch up later. I like to share my thoughts about the song, “You Can,” later when I get back.
By: eunice on November 30, 2008
at 3:56 am
Good read as usual John. Mmmm…. here’s my take on You Can:
I was a little distracted and amused by his “Andrea Bocelli” vibe the 1st time I viewed that performance haha! I’m not sure if this was his last song of the set (order of performance) but he may be a little spent here and did the least change up on this song.
I felt he was a little conscious abt the technicalities, so the connection may not be that perfect. Then again, there were some really nice parts – eg the bridge (the subtle angst at “and I know…”) and I love love love the last “can” – the note and the expression was priceless. Even on the audio – I heard those expressions so clearly – and to me – those subtle parts made this restraint delivery brilliant.
This performance may have been overshadowed by TMH and MH – both which I really love the changes he made to the arrangements and which I felt he connected brilliantly (yes, despite running out of breath on the extremely difficult-to-sing MH)!
On a lighter note – I was trying to listen between Hitz and Fly on my mobile, at the wet market, this morning – and Crush came on abt the same time lol! So fill me in guys – I think Crush was no3 on both the charts – but did the djs say anything worth noting?
By: Elicia on November 30, 2008
at 2:16 pm
love the review john
i keep going back to ALTNOY and TMH over and over…and over…again.lol.
but i missed the countdown today..totally knocked out.lol.
elicia-crush was #3 on both charts
Anne
By: Archuleta Avenue Msia on November 30, 2008
at 5:24 pm
Thks Anne – looks like its no3 across all the charts – Hitz, Mix, Fly and MTV lol!
My fave fm AOL is actually MH and TMH lol! I love how he changed them up, and I really love the arrangement – some interesting guitar and keyboard elements were added – kudos to the Musical Director I shld say?
Like you John, I like but don’t love Barriers. So TMH shld be the 3rd single – a breakaway fm the pop styling of Crush and ALTNOY. I wld also love for MH to be a single although it seems to be the least loved by the fans lol!
By: Elicia on November 30, 2008
at 9:49 pm
Ok, I am so glad I get to pick my brain here.
I felt that since he was kind of lipsinging in this AOL sessions, it did not project the accurate feelings he was delivering. He was closing his eyes most of the time while singing this song.
Sitting on a stool and singing,”You Can” had kind of limited his free expression and movements.
Moreover, You Can is a story about finally meeting the very person he has been waiting for.
A soul mate, the one whom he has been dreaming of. Just imagine, sinigng this song sitting down, that will restrain the flow of all the elated joy, passion etc…….
I am trying to illustrate this point with this story…
I was shopping the other day. I saw a couple, not young but middle age…40-50. Both of them were shopping for fruits, just next to me. The man walked around picking up fruits, then he teased the woman he was with. The woman was shy. I heard him laughing, just acting like a little teenager. He was like floating in the air, joyful, satisfied. I am sure they are new couple. Don’t ask me how I know, but I just know.
Then I looked around at couples who walked into the store. They talked to each other, normal conversation, and expressions. These are long time married couples! Hahaha. Dull interactions.
Unlike the first couple, full of joy, excitement and contentment, not a thing to worry about. They are not bothered by people around them, and engrossed with each other. The man actually leapt
when they were walking.
I hope you get the picture. What I am trying to say is that one cannot just sit and stare at the person you finally fall in love with. Of course, unless you are about to reveal to her/him about your feelings, that will be very NERVOUS for anyone!!
I felt like David was struggling to put the right feeling when he was singing You Can. If he imagined himself telling the girl about his feelings for her….that will spell NERVOUS. But if he imagined himself like the man who finally woo his girl, he would have a different expression…joy, etc….
So the question : What was he imagining when he was singing it this time?
Pardon me if I read too much into this song. I agree, I couldn’t figure out the emotion in this song either.
Just my 2 cents!!!!!
By: eunice on December 1, 2008
at 10:29 am
John, you nailed it once again
I thought that Crush was near-perfect! You Can made me recall what Andrew Lloyd Webber said during AI, “open your eyes, open your eyes”. hahahaha! I can tell that he was trying to lose himself in the song, but it didn’t seem to work. Other than that, I don’t think there is a doubt in the singing. LOL!
Elicia, I was thinking about the 3rd and 4th single the other day. And I found myself going “If this is the 3rd, and that the 4th, WHAT ABOUT ?!”. If Jive wants to take risks, then they may have YEDL as a single. I’m not the greatest fan of that song, but its a do-or-fail kind of single. It may fail big time, or may be a huge success like the random Umbrella song by Rihanna.
By: Lynn on December 1, 2008
at 10:40 am
Eunice – all the artistes on AOL do not lipsynch – that’s why it is called live sessions.
David wasn’t lip-synching – he may have more than 1 take I dunno. His body/facial expressions correlated well with the random exertions on his delivery throughout – so no, he wasn’t lip-synching!
By: Elicia on December 1, 2008
at 11:03 am
HI Elicia,
I know it was live but he sure looked like he was.
I hope I am not imagining things. I am not sure what was going on, whether it was due to the whatever mechanical stuff. I have viewed the clip several times. He was ok with the others except this song You can. I was surprised too when I saw it. Looked at his mouth carefully, it did not correlate throughout the delivery.
I hope I am watching the same clip you are watching.
By: eunice on December 1, 2008
at 11:46 am
John, excellent review & absolutely grateful for the articulation. You always say it so well.
“But the sessions have only reinforced the fact that David is an extraordinarily gifted vocalist especially when he sings live. It is as if he blooms and blossoms in full on the stage.”
David has always been an instinctive, rare musician thus he will change things on the spot, almost like he can’t help it, he sings it the way he feels it thus listening to him live can be such a musical experience.
As for You Can,I was watching youtube & I think there were technical glitches, the audio and visual not aligned, so I didnt really pay attention. I was hoping I have more time to try the AOL site later.
By: djarox13 on December 1, 2008
at 1:36 pm
Eunice – there are glitches when you stream from AOL and the particular youtube of You Can had some technical issues – the vid and audio did not sync. Sometimes when I stream it is ok, sometimes everything is out of sync – it has more to do with our internet speed and connection, and the traffic I guess
When I download the vids and rewatch on itunes player – they sync perfectly.
By: Elicia on December 1, 2008
at 1:58 pm
“AOL sessions- You can” which sync (by Davidarchieismyangel)
By: Anonymous on December 1, 2008
at 8:42 pm
Anonymous, thanks so much for the link.
Despite some lukewarm reviews on You Can @AOL, I think David delivered this without being too earnest. On the money, David, on the money!
I cant imagine when you grow up 3-4 yrs from now and kill us with your emotional power ballads.
By: Djarox13 on December 1, 2008
at 9:20 pm
i dont think he is lip syncing, but maybe he was using autotune on his mic (read somewhere on youtube)? I think the autotune thing is to tune his pitch to match the album’s pitch. Making him 100 on pitch.
But the more i think about it, i dont think david needs one, he always sings on pitch.
But the more i see the sessions, it just looks too perfect.
By: yxlee1990 on December 1, 2008
at 9:21 pm
Lip-synch or not – we will know if David can achieve the same AOL standard for his upcoming live performances. Frankly if he sings 85% of what he does on his album, he’s a fantastic live singer.
Autotune on his mic? I wonder why all the singers out there don’t use autotune on their mics….. then we should have a world of perfect pitch live singers….lol
By: Kylie on December 1, 2008
at 9:55 pm
haha! That make sense kylie.
For the record I’m just sharing what i saw on youtube.
I’m still a 100% david fan.
lol
By: yxlee1990 on December 1, 2008
at 10:07 pm
Wow…..how can every positive thing about David turned into something negative or doubtful?
SOMEONE, please, ask David pointedly and directly the questions about AOL. His eyes don’t lie.
By: Kylie on December 1, 2008
at 10:11 pm
Chill.
lol
By: yxlee1990 on December 1, 2008
at 10:20 pm
http://forums.vh1.com/vh1/board/message?board.id=5fe6cff4a63a12332d388d8377dcf48f&thread.id=6676&view=by_date_ascending&page=4
just found this link, it explains everything.
By: yxlee1990 on December 1, 2008
at 10:22 pm
yxlee, lol, I am not directing at you and I know you are sharing what’s happening in the Archu-Cyber-World. I just began reading these stuff at IDf and I think I’ll give up already.
By: Kylie on December 1, 2008
at 10:24 pm
Sure…chilling…
lol
By: Kylie on December 1, 2008
at 10:26 pm
Ladies, no singer as consummate as David Archuleta will lip sync unless it is absolutely practical option due to back to back performance or medical conditions.
Knowing David, he will never settled for lip-sync coz e is no millie vanillie.
How can anyone budding young artisit agree to lip sync? Isnt it called live session?
By: Djarox13 on December 1, 2008
at 10:29 pm
Millie vanillie lip-synch???? Hmm…I was deceived.
DJArox, some people think that David’s AOL sessions are just too perfect when they compare to other singers’ sessions. They cited You Can plus ALTNOY high notes (where they cut to the guitars for no apparent reasons??!!!) as evidences that David’s voice was processed or tinkered with. And according to them, “processed” is not equals to lip-synch.
Then, there’s a bunch of explanation about what AOL Live Sessions are all about.
No one really know what went on, except the guys & AOL people. So asking them is the best option…I guess.
By: Kylie on December 1, 2008
at 10:42 pm
Hmmm…. I don’t think that David sounded or looked as if he was lip-synching. I am a bit confused here. Kylie, so you mean people have been saying that David’s voice was PROCESSED, but he did not lip-sync? This whole thing is getting very very interesting. I think we should just sit back and enjoy the sessions. hehehe…. :p
Dja, are you back from your holiday? Hope you enjoyed your holiday!
By: Lynn on December 1, 2008
at 10:52 pm
Lol we don’t need the drama here as well. No artiste lip-synch on AOL period. I’ve glossed thru some of the others – they are not that bad and there are some great performances out there. Probably just that David’s were great 5 out of 5.
Whatever treatment was done, if any, was equal to what other artistes had – it is as simple as that. And yes, his vocals were on top of the pile – is that supposed to be a surprise? Wasn’t it an acknowledged fact that he is one of the best vocalist around?
The final sound was definitely remixed for a better effect – but not to the extend of autotuning (rolls eyes!). He doesn’t get special treatment here… he’s just special…. case closed.
I dunno why everyone wants to believe that one person (whatever his background) on VH1 – who only saw the Crush performance, and who is not a fan of David’s voice in the first place. Lots of haters are in denial of his talent – but why shld this shake our faith in him? If he managed to sing those songs in the studio recordings for the album, he definitely is able to do it live – it was reported he didn’t need autotuning in the studio, so why does he need it for AOL? Wldn’t it be easier to just do a few extra takes to get it right?
By: Elicia on December 1, 2008
at 10:56 pm
he didn’t need autotune in the studio? WOW!
haha, what the hack is autotune actually?
lol
By: yxlee1990 on December 1, 2008
at 11:02 pm
Haha, Lynn…welcome to the world of confusion.
There is a group saying he lip-synched. Another group say “processed”. And another group say he used autotune on his mic. Also another group saying he was amazing live. And oh, one group is confused.
I agree…the whole AOL discussion has skyrocketed into another realm. Interesting….
yxlee, just to make sure, I was not directing any comment at you.
I know too well of the internet. I was reading some of these stuff that prompted me to comment that there will always be groups of people debating and over-analyzing things David do. Such a fine line between that and constructive criticism. David said before that he doesnt mind criticism and yeah we don’t need to protect him from any negative reviews. It just gets tiring reading all the back and forth arguments and not able to just enjoy what David’s singing. Singing is an art and art is subjective.
By: Kylie on December 1, 2008
at 11:06 pm
haha! Kylie, chills, no worries.
ps i’m in the confused group now.
By: yxlee1990 on December 1, 2008
at 11:12 pm
I think ppl won’t stop until something sensational like this happens:
“David Archuleta has been lip-synching all along. The real voice behind the phenomenal teenager is Jeff Archuleta!”
That wld totally overshadow the Milli Vanilli fiasco, period.
By: Elicia on December 1, 2008
at 11:14 pm
ELICIA, NOW THAT MADE MY NIGHT!!!!!!
You are hilarious. JEFF ARCHULETA FTW!!!!!
By: Kylie on December 1, 2008
at 11:16 pm
Kylie – since you’re here – I need to clarify some things:
The album debuted at no6 on World Chart – am I right?
And in the Billboard article, it was reported he has sold 1.4million digital downloads to date (as of late October I think). – am I right?
By: Elicia on December 1, 2008
at 11:19 pm
I’m just tired Kylie – dunno why ppl are surprised he can sing so well live when it has always been a given fact. I remember fm Dean’s book – David came to him ‘pitch-perfect’…. And he was pitch perfect 99.9% of the time on AI anyway (the one time he wasn’t – he was sick).
By: Elicia on December 1, 2008
at 11:26 pm
Elicia,
1.4mil digital downloads as reported by Billboard is correct pertaining to Crush? That was the week when Crush has sold 991k downloads. Some have been figuring where the difference came from.
No:6 debut on world chart….this one I have to check on.
By: Kylie on December 1, 2008
at 11:28 pm
Kylie – not just Crush- probably inclusive of the singles fm the album.
I think I saw the world chart thing on IDF – have to check back the threads haha!
Was just complaining to Ai Sim – Crush spins dropped by half on Fly, and no ALTNOY until Loveit/Shoveit. What gives? I called Steve for ALTNOY today and he said see what he can do – but ultimately didn’t spin it.
They do spin 2 songs from 1 singer – note Neyo – they still spin Closer and loads of Ms Independent. How to get ALTNOY on the MWC if non-fans don’t even get to hear it?
By: Elicia on December 1, 2008
at 11:35 pm
Oh I got it – no6 debut on Billboard world chart. And the downloads – I think it is inclusive of ringtone and music vid sale.
I just downloaded the itunes ringtone – fun stuff as you can select the part of the song you want. Reason being I can’t use the ringtones on sale locally for my iphone!?!
By: Elicia on December 1, 2008
at 11:48 pm
Elicia, ALTNOY was just for spot spins…I think it means selected spins. Fly Fm chose MWC debut on Thursday, then once on Friday plus Loveit/Shove it slots. Other than that they have towait until the official release date? Ask Sony when you see them.
Really, the Billboard figure includes whole album, other single dls? Yeah, when I have some time, I go dig out these threads.
But YAY!!!!! for doing well, David!!!!
By: Kylie on December 1, 2008
at 11:53 pm
Dja – yay ure back!we missed u!!its been so long since we’ve seen u around!!
btw, regarding the ‘lip synching’ theory abt the AOL sessions..i came across an explaination by soundscene in IDF that is pretty informative.hope this helps =)
“The audio is recorded directly from the mics of David and the band. The audio and video are recorded separately. The audio is taken, it is mixed and mastered. I doubt they autotune the vocals (or we would see that more often with others). They might increase or decrease the volume, which may or may not have an effect on the tonal quality of the vocals.
They then take the mixed and mastered audio and overlay it on the video, sometimes resulting in the video looking like the sound isn’t actually coming directly from David’s mouth. The same technique is used with live concert DVDs because video recording equipment cannot pick up the sound correctly, nor would they want to have to separate the audio from the video after the fact.
So are the vocals messed with? Yes. Did they autotune David? I doubt it. Does David sound awesome live? Most definitely? Did he do a better job with his Sessions than most artists? Yes.”
trudi(also from idf) also testified to the fact that david did not lip sync:
“His voice was not processed or “sweetened” or pitch perfected or digitally altered to sound different then what actually came out of his mouth. This is the way he sounds live. If you went to an AI concert you would know this.
The sounds of the instruments may have been balanced so not to overpower his voice. That’s it.”
As for me, do i think David lip-synced? Heck, no. If there’s one singer who would not lip sync unless he has absolutely no choice(eg.Macy Parade), it’s David.
Anne
By: Archuleta Avenue Msia on December 2, 2008
at 12:15 am
hahahaha… the world of confusion. Elicia, the problem is, there hasn’t been a sensational singer like David probably since some 10 years ago! Everyone has probably gotten used to singers like the Jobros and those random singers who basically can’t even sing(sorry if I just offended anyone, but I just can’t stand the Jobros, sorry!). It takes time for them to realize
Kylie, so basically we can only listen to ALTNOY once a day on Love it or Shove it until the 9th of Dec??? Dang…. By the way, did ALTNOY win tonight? I missed it!
By: Lynn on December 2, 2008
at 12:17 am
Anne, thanks for the info! This whole thing is honestly very interesting! I wish I could learn more about how it works. I think its time for more Google-ing!
I love Google, they make my life way easy.
By: Lynn on December 2, 2008
at 12:22 am
lynn – ALTNOY won loveit/shove it again tonight
and guess who was the lucky winner? our very own Justine! LoL.
but no crush in MWC!We need to requesttt!
and google.lol..at times they are very helpful..at times,of no use at all hahah!
Anne
By: Archuleta Avenue Msia on December 2, 2008
at 12:27 am
btw, the link yxlee gave earlier :
its by soundscene too.
http://forums.vh1.com/vh1/board/message?board.id=5fe6cff4a63a12332d388d8377dcf48f&thread.id=6676&view=by_date_ascending&page=4 basically explains everything indeed. take a look
Anne
By: Archuleta Avenue Msia on December 2, 2008
at 12:29 am
Lynn…not 100% sure about ALTNOY situation at Fly Fm. It was classified as “spot plays”. I have yet to find an accurate definition of that. My explanation is based on my own theory and observation.
By: Kylie on December 2, 2008
at 7:45 am
Anne, yes I am back from my holidays and thank you for the very warm welcome back. Unfortunately, I have some work crisis.
AOL sessions are basically live stints and all I care was David having the opportunity to experience it.
Ignore the autotune stuff coz its equivalent to “should we have purple balloons for Christmas or should we stick to the white & Green balloons ?People who are dying to discredit David Archuleta are people who dont get him, nothing bad about that. I dont get David Cook, And nobody, I repeat, nobody dare come up to me and inquire, David Cook is awesome cos I will say, good for you. Then the evil part in me takes over & say;
I like that you are a young conformist rock fan. “have you heard “Band on the run” by Beatles? Nope,? What about Sister golder hair?
I have never met anyone younger than me who gushes over Sister golden hair except Mr Dja & my boss who thinks I have impeccable taste in music. So, for our young angel s & archies, if your boss is about 40ish to 60ish, you dedicated these songs to them & I guarantee you they think you are an alien:)
Band on the run by Beatles
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6XDI5pw-UrI
Sister golden hair by America
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCc53eTwD9k
So sad, they dont make music like this any nore!
Where’s my adorable Jun Hou?
By: Djarox13 on December 3, 2008
at 6:56 pm